PCMech Report


Go Back   PCMech Forums > Help & Discussion > Computer Hardware

Closed Thread
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread Rate Thread Display Modes
Old 05-08-2005, 03:23 PM   #1
fedz
GFX Techman
 
fedz's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: The kingdom United
Posts: 1,316
What Power Supply should I get? How many Watts? Who made it? Guide Inside

Please see updated thread. This thread is no longer maintained, and has migrated to the new thread.


01.19.09 EDIT: Added links to "Further Links" to include FiringSquad Unofficial PSU Guide - a link brought to my attention by nicolaus corelius. Also, organized the Further Links section into Unordered Lists. If you have any other suggestions, please contact me via PM. Thanks - Moderator.

Table of Contents:
-Five Important Rules to follow for Power Supply Unit (PSU) selection
-Good/Bad Units List
-General wattage calculator
-Further Links
-Who Really Made this Power Supply Unit? (thanks to flazing1)
-Notes
-Disclaimer


This is a locked update from Bigandy's superb thread. It takes into account all the comments posted, and I have personally researched all the brands to ensure that the information is up to date. Also, read the disclaimer at the bottom.

Five Important Rules to follow for Power Supply Unit (PSU) selection:
In no particular order
1) Do NOT skimp on the power supply unit - you are entrusting an expensive investment you've made in your computer to this unit.
2) Brand/Manufacturer reputation is VERY important
3) Rated/Advertised Wattage is NOT an indicator of quality or unit power.
4) Do NOT trust a PSU that weighs less than your CPU to power your system.
5) Research - let others do the testing for you and read about them. That's what this thread is for.



NOTE: To emphasize the point, "reputable" generally refers to companies that make high quality units while "Less Reputable" refers to manufacturers that produce normally faulty units. Like with any electronic product, there is a chance of failure with any unit, so please keep that in mind as you shop for a power supply unit.


Reputable:1
Top quality PSU's in blue - for high-end builds

AMS
Antec
Astec
AOpen (select models)
Channel Well
Corsair
Delta
E-Power
Enermax
Enlight
Fortron Source

HEC
Hi-Power
HiperPower
Jeantech
Mad Dog
Mushkin
NSpire
OCZ (esp. EvoStream and GameXStream)
PCMCIS
PC Power & Cooling
PowerMan
Raidmax (select models from Tagan/Topower)
Seasonic
SilenX
Silverstone
Sparklepower
Tagan
Thermaltake (select models)
TTGI/SuperFlower (select models)
Verax
Zalman
Xclio (only GreatPower)
Questionable/Less Reputable:

Achieve
Allied
Apevia (formerly Aspire, same quality)
Bestec
Codegen
CoolMax
Cyberzone
DEER
Dragon
Eagle Tech
EYE-T
Greenline
HIPRO
JSP-tech
KingStar
Kingwin
L&C
Linkworld
Okia
Orion
PowerMagic
PowerTek
PowerUp
Powmax
Q-Tec
Raidmax (with cases)
Rosewill
Skyhawk
Startech
Turbolink
Ultra (esp. X-Connect)
Vantec
Win
Not Enough Info:

AGPB
Ahanix
Dynapower USA
Levicom
Soyo





General PSU Calculators:
Please note these should be used as GUIDES - as noted on their disclaimers, they cannot take into account every component, every part that is drawing power. As a general guidelines, it's a good idea to marginally overshoot the calculated wattage in order to cover for the entire system.

eXtreme PSU Calculator

http://www.jscustompcs.com/power_supply/

http://www.pcpowercooling.com/maxpc/cases.htm

Above links courtesy of Pancake, Fedz, bill_bright, and glc.




Further links:
courtesy of Hi Ho, flazing1, Panama Red, Cricket, Freakitchen, and glc




Notes:

- PSU's inside manufacturer's cases, like Dell or HP, can sometimes use power supply units that may or may not be sufficient to allow for upgrades. In other words, you may need to upgrade your PSU in the real chance that the unit cannot handle the added load. Take note, and do your research first.

- Dell has often been using PC P&C for their PSU. HP, eMachine, Compaq, and Gateway USUALLY use either/or Bestec and Hipro.

- Modular PSU's are not all good. The connections are not very efficient and provide a lot of electrical resistance. In fact, I just avoid them.




DISCLAIMER:
Although some PSU's are listed in the good list, this does not mean that they are never going to fail. No component is ever perfect, these power supplies just have a higher success rate and generally provide cleaner, more efficient power.
The same goes for the 'bad' PSU's. Just because you have a 'bad' PSU it does not mean that it is going to fail on you the next day. These PSU's have been reported as problematic and there is a higher probability of them giving out, or at least not providing clean power through stable rails. There is also the matter of 'rated power'. Some "500W" power supplies have been known to provide less than 200W, whereas some good quality PSU's can provide more power than their rating.

Quote:
Originally Posted by JonnyGURU
http://www.jonnyguru.com/modules.php?name=NDReviews&op=Story5&reid=71

It was hard to pick a winner among losers, but the clear leader of the pack would have to be the Delta DPS300-PB-1, if for no other reason than it actually still worked after we got done with it.
__________________
If it's broke, fix it
If it ain't, overclock it
-------------------------
http://img64.exs.cx/img64/309/mypc8ursmall2ts.png

Last edited by kram 2.0; 06-12-2009 at 05:33 PM.
fedz is offline  
Old 01-07-2009, 10:45 PM   #2
kram 2.0
Member (13 bit)
 
Join Date: Aug 2003
Location: Richmond, VA
Posts: 7,835
Power Supply OEM List legend
(taken from http://forums.nvidia.com/index.php?showtopic=4146)

#1a
Topower
(some TTGI - Super-Flower, OCZ, EPower/Tagan, RaidMax, Vantec, ACI)

#1b
FSP - Fortron Source Power
(Fortron, Sparkle, Cooler Master*, Zalman, Aopen)

#1c
CWT - Channel Well Technology
(Antec, Lead Power, Enermax, Xclio, Turbolink)

While these top three encompass more than the re-badges I've named, you can usually bet on a solid performer if you pick one of them. It's highly debatable which are better than others, of course. But all in all, everyone has had pretty good experiences. Not suprisingly, they are priced accordingly. None of them in the 400W range are going to be under $50. If your power supply is one of the above, chances are you can trust both the unit itself and it's claims on wattage per line.


#2a
Sea Sonic

#2b
Wintech
(Ultra X-finity)

#2c
Acbel Polytech
(Stateside, just the Cooler Master True Power)

Same with these, a bit more esoteric. If you can afford a Sea Sonic these have the best efficiency of any consumer switching PSU for computers. You'll pay for it up front, but your electric bill will be less in the long run.


#3a
Sirtec
(Chieftec, Enlight, ThermalTake, High Power)

#3b
HEC - HeroIchi Electronic Co.
(HEC, CompuCase)

#3c
AMS - American Media Systems
(Mercury)

Here you start finding dissention in the owners. Some claim it's the best in the world, some wouldn't let their dog run Windows 3.11 on one. Some of them have great reputations (TT & HEC) but the problem is a "squeaky wheel" one - it's hard to know just how good/bad things are when only people with problems post.


#4a
Youngyear
(Aspire, Logisys, MGE, Ultra X-Connect, Rosewill)

#4b
ATNG
(Coolink, CoolMax, Rosewill, StarTech)

Now we're into budget territory. Maybe it's just a quality control issue; some people love them but most hate them, and from bad personal experiences. I personally wouldn't touch them. They should work, but no one will be suprised if it smokes itself and takes your motherboard with it. They rarely come close to what their ratings state, very poorly constructed. (but usually colors or chrome and UV sleeved and colored Molex's and LED fans!) These for the most part are toys, although you might get lucky. Not all of them are, but it does take more effort in sifting through them than it's worth.


#5
CRAP!
(L&C, Deer, Allied, Eagle, CodeGen/Foxconn, EverPower, Maxpower)
__________________
"For today, goodbye. For tomorrow, good luck. And forever, Go Blue!"
University of Michigan President Mary Sue Coleman
kram 2.0 is offline  
Closed Thread

Bookmarks

Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes Rate This Thread
Rate This Thread:

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is On

Forum Jump

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Need HELP with Power Supply swap! paul441 Computer Hardware 15 01-26-2007 10:16 PM
How do I test power supply. mikemnf Computer Hardware 11 01-13-2006 08:51 AM
How much watts does my Power Supply gives? KoRn_KId Computer Hardware 2 10-24-2004 04:52 AM
Installing a Power Supply mike breck Windows Tips, Tricks, and Tweaks 2 01-09-2003 04:22 PM
Finally, a "good" and common power supply *SPI*(sparkle) Toaster Computer Hardware 13 03-30-2002 12:48 AM


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 02:53 PM.
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.